Top 5 Waterfront Communities in Toms River

Toms River isn’t just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle defined by the water. Whether you’re looking for a deep-water dock for your center console, a quiet cove for kayaking, or a beach house where the salt air wakes you up, our local communities offer some of the best waterfront living in New Jersey.

If you’re dreaming of life on the Barnegat Bay or the Toms River, here are the top five waterfront communities you should have on your radar.

1. Green Island

Located in the northern section of the Barnegat Bay, Green Island is a boater’s paradise. This unique peninsula is surrounded by the Bay and Kettle Creek, offering incredible 270-degree views.

• The Vibe: A tight-knit, multi-generational community with a “small-town” feel.

• Key Feature: The Green Island Community Association (GICA). Members get access to two private beaches, a clubhouse, and year-round social events like “Crab Races” and sunset yoga.

• Best For: Active families who want a private beach club lifestyle.

2. Silverton

As one of the most popular neighborhoods in Toms River, Silverton offers a diverse range of waterfront options, from cozy lagoon-front ranches to sprawling custom estates.

• The Vibe: Suburban and family-friendly with easy access to shopping and parks.

• Key Feature: Proximity to Silverton Park and local marinas. Many homes here feature private vinyl bulkheads and docks, allowing you to be on the open bay in minutes.

• Best For: Boating enthusiasts looking for a mix of suburban convenience and aquatic access.

3. Shelter Cove

Shelter Cove is centered around the massive Shelter Cove Park, making it one of the most amenity-rich waterfront spots in town.

• The Vibe: Energetic and outdoorsy.

• Key Feature: The park itself! It features a bayfront beach, soccer fields, tennis courts, and a playground. It’s the rare spot where you can play a game of softball and then walk a few feet to watch the sunset over the bay.

• Best For: Families with kids who need space to run and play both on and off the water.

4. Ortley Beach

While technically a part of Toms River, Ortley Beach sits on the barrier island, tucked between Lavallette and Seaside Heights. This is true “Shore” living.

• The Vibe: Classic Jersey Shore charm with a laid-back, walkable atmosphere.

• Key Feature: Oceanfront and Bayfront access. You can surf in the Atlantic in the morning and enjoy a calm bay sunset in the evening.

• Best For: Those who want a vacation home feel or a primary residence where the beach is your backyard.

5. Windsor Park

Located along the shores of the Barnegat Bay near the Toms River Yacht Club, Windsor Park offers some of the most tranquil coastal views in the area.

• The Vibe: Quiet, scenic, and slightly more secluded.

• Key Feature: Many homes in Windsor Park are situated on wide lagoons or direct bayfront lots with private docks. It feels like a hidden retreat while still being close to downtown Toms River dining.

• Best For: Retirees or buyers looking for a peaceful, “vacation-at-home” atmosphere.

Looking to make a move?

The waterfront market in Toms River moves fast, and each of these communities has its own unique nuances regarding bulkheads, flood zones, and dock depths.

Contact John Salemi today to get a curated list of available waterfront homes or a free valuation of your current property!